A blog for reviews… that's really not much of a blog

Foreword: Well, this was actually quite an unexpected surprise. While expecting a full-on charage with themes of astrology, this game presents some pretty vague but definite symbolism which I didn’t find myself catching at first. Like with the previous title I’ve reviewed, Sakura no Uta, this title also seems to have a very poetic ring. This really makes me think that Pulltop is at least decent with producing games (as seen with a great game called Natsuiro Recipe)

Title: 見上げてごらん、夜空の星を (miagete goran, yozora no hoshi wo) [Lit. Trans: Look up, to the stars in the night sky]
Producers: Pulltop
Release Date: December 18, 2015
VNDB Link: https://vndb.org/v16560
Getchu Link: http://www.getchu.com/soft.phtml?id=842090
Game Type: Poetic Novel revolving around astrology and themes of “stars”

Summary: Akito hikes up into the forest to the abandoned train station, where he enjoys his morning coffee and looking off into space. Ever since he fought with his childhood friend Hikari and had a bitter separation, he decided to not go stargazing anymore, but always had this “morning ritual” before he would devote his day to schoolwork and part time jobs at the Sawotome Convenience Store.

It’s been 6 years since that day when Hikari disappeared, and the friends around him suggest that he move on. The truth is though, Akito is still hesitant and scared and would rather be called that one “Astrology Member who never looks at Stars”.

This is when he receives an invitation to visit another school’s astrology club from his own club’s head. Mostly heading over to politely decline whatever they had to offer, the president offers to recruit him into the Mutsurashi Conference, or a group of people who want to share the beauty of the skies with everyone.

The “leader” of said Conference, Orihime

Story Length: Moderate (20 hours)
Complete Story Clearing Difficulty: Easy
Comments: The first choice of what to do with the letter splits the game into two arcs; one with Saya and Hikari, the other with Corona and Orihime. The route then splits again into said heroine routes, so I don’t think anyone would have too much trouble.

Character Design Rating: 7/10
Story Rating: 6/10
Protagonist Rating: 3/10
Game Quality: High
Overall Rating: 6/10
Rating Comments: A mediocre game, which has its goods and bads, so let’s try to go through them.

First Character Design. Generally well done, I enjoyed the various plethora of subcharacters who worked as support characters throughout the game and within routes. This especially worked well since other heroines still participate in each route (with the exception of Hikari who completely disappears in the Corona/Orihime arc). While the main heroines seemed a bit more generic (osananajimi, tomboy, senpai/kouhai), I still found them to be more colorful than what I would find a normal galge with traits that I’ll discuss later in the character sections.

Story is decent at best. Sure, there are those scenes where the game “teaches” its readers about the various stars, shapes, and technology used in astrology using highlights within the main game, but that’s really all there is to the story. The rest is essentially the same old “club activity” storyline prevalent in a lot of other galge. If at all, I gave story a bit of a higher score because of the poetic ring, the ambiguous symbolism at the end, and maybe the love triangle that Pulltop attempted to pull off (pun not intended) in the Saya/Hikari arc.

Protagonist is really what makes this game go into the gutter more than anything else. Seemingly normal, the only thing that separates him from any other male astrology club members was his past history with Saya and Hikari. If at all, while he does have the insights of an astrology member (and maybe the diligence), it wasn’t particularly outstanding, nor was he a great of an individual for the game to attempt to have a full-on love triangle for.

Basically, Akito was too normal and boring as this game’s protagonist, in addition to several other designs ultimately creating a minus more than anything else (e.g. his firm determination to never look at stars but changes his mindset at the beginning of the game without much happening). Even within the game, the heroines are never given that “romantic transition” with Akito, making this game also have one of the worst types of romantic development; aka, none.

Character Summary:

So despite how the game presents the characters, it’s actually recommended to go through Orihime and Corona’s routes first, since the producers put a lot more effort into Hikari/Saya’s arc.

So Orihime. She’s the club head who calls out Akito after hearing he was the “club member who never looks at stars” and tries to convince him to join the Mutsurashi Conference due to him having a great amount of knowledge for astrology. As an upperclassman 2 years older than Akito, she’s ironically shown to be more childish and playful than what we would normally expect from a “senpai” archetype, and loves anything to do with astrology or horoscopes, seen by her using tarot cards to create a first impression on Akito the very first day they meet.

Voiced by Tono Soyogi, I thought this was a very good match for Orihime’s character; mature but playful. The entire character needed a relatively serious, but cheerful atmosphere, for which I think Tono Soyogi was a perfect fit.

Orihime’s route mostly involves how she is approaching graduation, but never really “created a legacy” as she hoped to do during her school-days. She had gotten her love for astrology from her mother, but always compared herself to her, causing herself even more distress than she needed to.

Next is Corona, the younger sister of Takeichi and as the readers will quickly see, she has a huge crush on Akito from since their childhood since she compared her brother to the calm and solemn protagonist. Even more childish than Orihime, this is to be expected since she’s younger than Akito. In addition to this, Corona expresses her disdain for Saya quite liberally, which is answered in her own route.

Despite this, it is shown that Corona is heavily protected and very intelligent. It’s always been a complaint to her that during every event that occurs in the game, she is left out purely because her mom wouldn’t let her go out and play with friends, and instead made her study at home. Also because of this, Corona is relatively ignorant about the outside world, and has no idea what she wants to do with her future.

Overall, routes for both Orihime and Corona really lacked impact, and both heroines did better as a subcharacter than heroines themselves. Especially for Orihime, who outside of her own route, was “graduated” and never really made a contribution anyways.

Despite how it seems like Hikari is the main heroine, it’s actually Saya who’s considered the “Central Heroine” since she plays a role within all four routes unlike the tomboy heroine. Immediately recognized with the gold/blue heterochromia, this has been her taboo since she was young, but in my honest opinion, heterochromia is pretty damn sexy.

My perverted opinion aside, it seems that Saya has been with Akito for as long as they can remember, from when Saya transferred to their kindergarten and up until high school. From a third-person’s perspective, she almost looks like Akito’s girlfriend, often bringing him food to the school she doesn’t even attend (they attend different schools) almost to the point Saya accepts and becomes fond of the title “Traveling Wife”. In reality, it’s obvious that a girl so loyal holds a very large amount of affection for the protagonist, who doesn’t really think of it too much until much later.

As mentioned previously, Saya and Hikari are involved in a full-blown love triangle which is prevalent in both routes (so this is a good trait!), but it’s neglected to a large extent in Saya’s route much to my disappointment. Instead, Saya’s route focuses more on the past of her and Akito, which then becomes the implied symbolism for Saya’s route; that “Stars are the representation of the Past”.

Overall, Saya as a character was pretty adorable, though like with all the other heroines, the transition of the romantic interest on behalf of Akito was completely lacking and even Saya herself had only flimsy “past events” which kept her being so loyal (which was rather unrealistic). She plays a role in all the other routes making her the “central heroine”, but the game makes it so as if Hikari is the “main heroine”. While ambiguous, I think this works well because of the love-triangle present in both routes.

Now only if Akito would have been more of a protagonist than he was >.>;;

Hikari is the red-haired tomboy who fought with Akito in the past and disappeared. Despite this, she was essentially Akito’s motivation to live and go stargazing, so after her disappearance, Akito felt betrayed and disappointment for this character more than anything. However, as fate turns out, Hikari returns to the town with her father’s continuous changing of jobs (I like how this game pulls in the parents to play a part in the story, but it’s more as a “restrictive” role more than an encouraging one for their children), and both Saya and Akito are completely surprised to see the return of this character who they never thought would be able to see again.

With the return of Hikari, Akito seems to be more willing to go stargazing again, and starts to become involved a bit more. While I generally thought this was a good transition, Hikari’s route also involved the crappiest transition to romance with a large portion of the mid-section being Hikari refusing Akito’s confession multiple times because of feeling obligated to Saya, but changing that mindset suddenly after a certain scene. To be honest, I thought Hikari’s route had the romance with the LEAST amount of validity because even for characters like Orihime and Corona, Akito never really had that “negative emotion” of feeling betrayed suddenly transitioning into love for absolutely no reason. While said “past conflict” was explicitly resolved at least in her route, there should have been much more taken for the two characters to slowly regain that trust they once lost for each other, and thus the romance seemed abrupt and crude.

In addition to this, Hikari herself disappears permanently within two of the routes anyways, so I thought it was pretty damn retarded for Pulltop to “try” to make her a main heroine as such (via making her more conspicuous on the cover, etc…) Regardless, Hikari’s route itself has a bunch of conflict going on which made it at least worth reading. The resolution felt awfully convenient though, but people who have already went through the game can debate about this a bit more.

Let’s also debate whether Saya or Orihime make the better “Traveling Wife”!

Sexual Content: Moderate

Comments: So some comments. I actually quite like how in the beginning, there were “animated” backgrounds pretty much right off the bat. This really enhanced the “visual” feature, and it doesn’t stop there; the game also uses various highlights to mark some of the constellations, which was a big bonus since it teaches the readers about what the characters are discussing.

Some of the negatives might be that other than Saya/Hikari, Orihime and Corona as a whole seemed very insignificant. It’s almost as if the writers simply attached them as somewhat of a “bonus” to the main storyline, although it’s true that these routes briefly touch on the identity of specific subcharacters and necessary in that sense. Both deviate quite heavily from the symbolism of stars and may not even hold a “quote” as the writers included for Saya and Hikari. For the reference, they are as follows:

Saya: The Stars represent the Past and History

Hikari: The Stars represent the Infinite Possibilities (thus the future)

The possibility of being able to explain this scenario without looking absolutely ridiculous? Near zero

Which actually worked pretty nicely in contrast… though on the other hand, it seems that this is the only “symbolism” that the game expresses at all, making the entire game seem like a charage. I say this because within the game, there’s very little seriousness and/or conflict. Sure, there’s that love-triangle, but it’s never resolved well, and problems arising from Project Starlight also gets resolved relatively conveniently: my impression as I finished the game was that it was all pretty anticlimactic.

In all honesty, I don’t think this game really warranted a fandisc (which was released quite recently). It involves characters who weren’t so important, so I think I’ll pass anyways.

…Now that I think about it, I think I may have had too high of an expectation after Natsuiro Recipes LOL

I don’t know if it’s because of the string of doujin/nukige I’ve been going through recently, but I was half-expecting a “harem” route of some sort.

I seriously think Akito’s design was quite unfortunate. I generally liked his traits of being so diligent and knowledgeable about astrology, but I really hated how he suddenly used the fight with Hikari as an excuse to not look at stars, came back to stargazing after seemingly not much conflict, falling in love with heroines for almost no reason and without a good transition (especially with Hikari), and generally not having impact on heroines in general.

Affection for the Characters: Moderately Low

CG Score: 8/10. Added a couple of points for all the animations to be honest, which really worked to the game’s benefit more than anything else
Music Score: 5/10. The game does have some nice soundtracks, but they never really added a mysterious or darker soundtrack as it would have been appropriate to represent Akito’s “uneasiness” when he went stargazing.

Addictiveness: Low

Conclusion:

Pros

  • The game includes various animations to enhance visuals as well as various highlights to teach the readers about constellations, if he wasn’t familiar with it already.
  • There is a definite attempt at one of the most difficult story elements; a love triangle. That in itself is worth a praise.
  • While the game does have archetypical character design, each heroine does have something unique about her that allows originality.
  • Subcharacters are well utilized to create conflict, act as support, and offer connections between main heroines or the protagonist
  • There are “flashbacks” well-placed at certain points within the game allowing for a good flow and pace.
  • Symbolism for the theme of this game (Stars) exist in the main routes, although it’s possible to argue that the lack of thereof in other routes also makes this a negative trait

Cons

  • Protagonist, while very diligent and admirable for the most part, is also someone you can’t really become too immersed with since his beliefs are rapidly overturned in the beginning of the game and he makes little impact on the heroines.
  • Romance is absolutely terrible in this game, and seriously makes me wonder why the producers even bother with it in the first place (I know it’s for H-scenes but still =_=)
  • Two of the four heroines are greatly insignificant and more of a “filler” than anything else

Overall, I would consider Miagete goran to be one of the “more decent charage”. I can’t really say it’s worthy of being a “good galge” because of its flaws in romance, protagonist design, and maybe even story to a certain extent (e.g. not having significance outside of “teaching” the readers about constellations). Because of this, I also cannot understand why there would be a fandisc for it in the first place, but then again there are inevitably people who are screaming that this is the best game ever (Protip: Twitter gives you cancer).

I would only recommend this game to players who actually enjoy storyline revolving around constellations and/or astrology, and advocate that if this isn’t the case, there are better options available.

Okay, I might go through the FD for Saya

Advertisements

Comments on: "The Stars Shine Whether or not You’re Looking at Them: Review of [151218] Miagete Goran, Yozora no Hoshi wo" (5)

  1. p.s. going through the FD just for saya is worth it <3

  2. I pretty much agree with you in most points. The two “crappy” routes didn’t really detract from my overall experience though. I’ve been told beforehand that those two are more like “omake” so I was reading with that kind of mindset from the beginning. If we only talk about the “main rotues,” it’s just like you say. The main problem is a lack of “transition” concerning akito’s feelings. it was super random.

    It wouldn’t have been THAT random if they added a couple more monologues and made the whole saya/hikari common branch belong to only saya, with a distinct, different branch for hikari. the way it is, there is literally zero in-between that justifies, or rather, shows us why he leans towards one or the other.

    I must say though, I didn’t consider it ‘that’ illogical that saya kept being in love with him for this whole time. what happened when they were kids was extremely impactful to her and it was generally also the happiest time of her life; if something with that much impact happens to someone at a small age and frequent reminiscence and, to a greater or lesser extent, over-glorification of the past comes into play, it’s not really surprising that these kind of feelings only keep growing stronger as time goes by if that person has nothing else that “balances the scale.”

    In Hikari’s case, the “out of nowhere” feeling is much stronger because they common route didn’t even show hints of her keeping these kind of emotions hidden or anything. it was only ex post facto (後付け). Tbh, the whole game feels like it has been written/designed around saya. she’s the only one where you really have that ピンとくる感じ. If you actually go out of your way and imagine there is no hikari route, and the hikari/saya shared part is all part of saya’s route, akito’s feelings don’t seem so random anymore. Hence, at least for me, it’s only saya’s route that has a natural flow looking at the game as a whole, while the rest feels forced.

    • It’s just as you say. The main reasons why I found Saya to be attractive was because of her great loyalty to Akito. Which is currently encouraging me to go on to experience the FD despite my backlog which is somehow larger than before (HOW?!)

      In terms of romance at least, it goes both ways; Protagonist -> Heroine, AND Heroine -> Protagonist. The source of affection for Saya FOR Akito is at least implied in the game, but everything else isn’t (e.g. Akito -> all four heroines, Hikari -> Akito). Quantitatively, the lack thereof for this “source” greatly outnumbers the scenarios for which affection is explained, so I counted this to be a very large negative trait, and I see you agree with me on this aspect.

      In reality, as mentioned in the game, Saya was THE central heroine by pure definition, although the game made attempts to make Hikari the “Main Heroine” which ended up failing.

  3. While the game is so-so in my opinion, i like corona’s character so i didnt regret playing this game.

    • This interests me. What did you like about Corona as a character? If at all, she was more of a imouto character than anything, and if there was a charm point about her, it was that she was holding that affection for Akito for a long time. Share with me what you liked about her!

Speak your Mind...

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: